HomeОбразованиеRelated VideosMore From: Archaeology Soup

In Focus: Ötzi "The Ice Man"

1474 ratings | 932163 views
Welcome to In Focus. In this series we take a closer look at particular sites, finds and objects from the world of Archaeology. *News* Ötzi's Genome Analysed: http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2012/02/120228123847.htm Blood Sample: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-17909396 Note: This is work is for the love of the topic, not for profit and essentially editorialistic in nature. It will never be televised or available outside of the YouTube platform. By definition, as a person who has not visited the museum all images belong to respective copyright holders though the nature of the work is transformative (in terms of context) and adds to the 'value' of the topic at hand.
Html code for embedding videos on your blog
Text Comments (344)
MUITO BOM
CoRRupted rIfT (5 days ago)
They said it had skin organs and everything nope hes a skeleton
hana elrifai (20 days ago)
No body knows how he he died but there are theories saying he died because he was shot by an arrow that’s why he has an injury to the back of his head.we are learning about this in highschool
MUFFIN man (1 month ago)
yes gooood mhmmm yes
MUFFIN man (1 month ago)
very epic thankyou thankyou lets invade canada
Rich Ratchford (1 month ago)
What if they found a tattoo of Brad Pitt on Otzi?
Archaeology Soup (1 month ago)
Rich Ratchford Whoa! Haha
John Howard (2 months ago)
The ice is what preserved the body.
John haworth (3 months ago)
Grave robbers
Alvin Engvall (3 months ago)
From alperna
Nevie Playz (4 months ago)
In my class, we are learning about early hoomans, and my teacher told us about Otzi.
Terri Smith (5 months ago)
The oldest cold case homicide on earth.
Lucky Slime (5 months ago)
I was in the museum. I saw the skeleton of him and learned a lot because of reading stuff about him.
priya malhotra (5 months ago)
Tomorrow we have a test about otzi
Archaeology Soup (5 months ago)
priya malhotra Then you should watch the more up-to-date version of this video :) Good luck. https://youtu.be/bZr-uAOJqo4
mr minecart (5 months ago)
you stupid
mr minecart (5 months ago)
thats right even scinetists
Archaeology Soup (5 months ago)
mr minecart *especially* scientists. Archaeologists and scientists start from a standpoint of knowing that we don’t know! :)
mr minecart (5 months ago)
no one knows how he deid
mr minecart (5 months ago)
you guys are all stupid
Sarahy Delacerda (7 months ago)
ALL THE PEOPLE THAT ARE SAYING HES DABBING YOUR SICK! AND SHOULD BE IN A MENTAL HOSPITAL!
Man in Ham (8 months ago)
Crank dat soulja boi
Kyle Rigoni (8 months ago)
pickle RICK!!!!!!!
Flash435 (8 months ago)
Good soup.
Kucing Galak (8 months ago)
Gw tau otzi dari channel MAQ
pooloolmool (9 months ago)
He dabbin
Bhanu prakash Venu (10 months ago)
Really amazing
ExoticButters_ BOI420 (11 months ago)
Lil man just dab infront of lil tourist.
Ben Quinney (11 months ago)
He’s hip,he’s cold,he’s 45
ASMR ForDays (11 months ago)
logic tell that : this hunter got kill right after making fire to make food . so another hunter found him because of the smoke of the fire , and killed him for the territory
Oakleaf700 (11 months ago)
A ''YEW''nique axe handle....made of Yew...were they aware of this pun?
Tom Riddle (1 year ago)
The world's first dabber.
lina sruy (1 year ago)
interesting
ιlғυмeιх pυвg (1 year ago)
Died:Addicted to Dabbing
Kristoffer R (1 year ago)
This is why i want to be cremated. No one is gonna dig my bones up in the future.
samdog166 (1 year ago)
It’s funny how I’m instinctively on Otzi’s side, like maybe he was a dick and deserved from shot the back lol
Kamilla Iqbal (1 year ago)
poor guy
Kev Stackz (1 year ago)
wow
Xavier Finesse (1 year ago)
Ughhh had to re watch this to do a report... Ain't social studies a blessing.
Archaeology Soup (1 year ago)
Playboi Finesse Should’ve watched the updated version :)
Emylee Miller (1 year ago)
why did they even show this guy in the ice tub not real smart
Archaeology Soup (1 year ago)
It was an illustrative image of someone very cold, not a literal attempt at reconstruction :) But yes, a little odd.
Toya B (1 year ago)
We learned this in school Friday
hugo hero (1 year ago)
Ötzi: ich hätt auch nicht gedacht, dass ich noch mal zu nem Wirtschaftsfakor in Südtirol wird...
Claude Röist (8 months ago)
hugo hero Italien ya?1?1?1
Darth Tyranus (1 year ago)
Isn't ötzi cursed....??????!!!!!????? I heard that everyone that had to do with him they died?
WolfA (6 months ago)
Ya think?
AH96 (1 year ago)
Those are just coincidences
Ryan mackay (1 year ago)
Archaeosoup Productions someone died in a car crash anther one in a avalanche and then someone else fell 300 the next died of a heart attack
Archaeology Soup (1 year ago)
No, no curse and lots of people who have researched Otzi are happily alive :D
corvid37 (1 year ago)
that old guy lifting up the corpse with his bare hands wtf
Filip Reuterberg (7 days ago)
Robert Allen This was before mobile phones and the internet. Its not like they could look stuff up on wikipedia while on the top of a mountain in 1991. They had to look in a phonebook and send letters and stuff after they realized it was not a normal death ;)
Peter Mavrakis (21 days ago)
Robert Allen at the time of the discovery they thought he was a recently killed hiker.
Robert Allen (25 days ago)
..where were all the responsible archaeologists/anthropologists when the Iceman was found? Why wasn't this done professionally?
Panda Paws (2 months ago)
Ikr
Alan (5 months ago)
The recovery guys really did fuck up some things. They damaged a bunch of the artefacts when they used Ice axes to hack away at the ice around him.
lewis taylor (1 year ago)
The quiver is actually made out of a type of goat skin
xd alikh idzam (1 year ago)
he was either a thief or a war HERO
Brianna Wallin (1 year ago)
some people say he's dabbing some people say he's sneezing but i say he's making history
Tom Riddle (1 year ago)
Brianna Wallin cringe
Queezy_ (2 years ago)
Hes pretty ugly in the facial recognition.
Fab4GameZ (2 years ago)
Otsi the Iceman oopsy! I meant otzi
Official Lainpalvoja_ (2 years ago)
Ötzi, the founder of dabbing
Official Lainpalvoja_ sadly
Katherine Scanlon (3 months ago)
😂 😂 😂
default with 13 subs (5 months ago)
*D A B*
Precious Ignacio (6 months ago)
+Sarahy Delacerda exactly
Sarahy Delacerda (7 months ago)
Official Lainpalvoja_ your sick
Jasmine W (2 years ago)
His cloes got frozen I wonder who shot orzo with a bow n arrow
Frenchiest Fry (2 years ago)
dat dab tho
Sophia Yt (2 years ago)
We had to work on Otzi things for SO LONG in ELA i literally know everything abt this man LMAO
Kelly turner (2 years ago)
in school
Kelly turner (2 years ago)
I'm learning about otzi
Declan Sheehan (2 years ago)
The first time I heard of this was in a video saying some believe Otzi to be cursed.
Rachel cupcakes (2 years ago)
I fond the book of this at school
Balaji G (2 years ago)
Who else came here after seen on FB ?? :)
Satanic Tea (2 years ago)
School.exe has lead me here
Big Mustard (2 years ago)
Shoutout to 2nd period World History!
Carmen Muniz (2 years ago)
thier is only one reason he died and that reason is for being STUPID!Who fucken goes to a fucking mountain😂
remprxv (1 year ago)
with a copper axe in the stone age!!!
jigglyt1t2 (2 years ago)
Cool
Maybe he was shot by his companion
Lucky Slime (5 months ago)
Yeah. He was shot on the back.
Emylee Miller (1 year ago)
the world will never know i am learning this is in my history class i know a good amount of it.
Archerfish Johns (1 year ago)
Boi
Asian Vibes (2 years ago)
Why do I have to talk about this in school?
ツTHATCRAZY_T (5 months ago)
Coco The Servant Of Jesus yeah
Elix _ (2 years ago)
+Coco The Servant Of Jesus same here
sessez (2 years ago)
same
I'm in 7th grade. we had to learn about it.
RAUL SOSA (2 years ago)
Excellent!
People: Yep lets name him Ötzi Ötzi: THAT IS NOT MY NAME
111 (2 years ago)
Ötzi must have been a bad dude have four different peoples' blood on three different weapons then he turns out to have an arrow in his side! Then a few people involved with him gets killed in mysterious accidents! Of course he probably didn't cause thus,but still. He might have been a criminal from southern Corsica according to his blood.
cityuser (2 years ago)
Did anyone else think Doctor Who when you saw those tattoos? .3.
akgeronimo501 (2 years ago)
5'2"?  He must have been Russian.
sclock2 (6 months ago)
Not really, Asian maybe
akgeronimo501 I am Russian and I am 6'1
akgeronimo501 (2 years ago)
+GAME STRONTJE Then you know I'm right.
GAME STRONTJE (2 years ago)
I am Russian
akgeronimo501 (2 years ago)
+GAME STRONTJE Russians are shorter than you think.  It is the first thing you notice when you see a bunch of them.  I was shocked at how little their Army guys were.   
About Life (2 years ago)
Still fabricating origins and teaching children lies. Shame on you.
EggaMooby Muffin (11 months ago)
I think she is upset that he isn't black...Which he was not
Cuck Hunt1488 (1 year ago)
"Still fabricating origins" What evidence do you have that this is fake, or are you just talking out of your ass? "and teaching children lies." That is a serious charge, that has no weight behind it "Shame on you." I think your the one who needs to be shamed.
olskoolnewpaint (2 years ago)
Dumbass
awsome productions (2 years ago)
ötze was found on a mountain omfg
Fest Theory (2 years ago)
FINALLY SOLVED: BECOMING HUMAN / INTELLIGENCE / AI. NEW COMPREHENSIVE THEORY STARTS FROM THE END by establishing the working theory of functioning of the human brain-IQ. https://evolutionofhumanintelligence.wordpress.com/ That is the only way to solve this puzzle and here is the only picture/story that makes sense. The human evolution ( 7 million years, 30 hominins ) must perform / accomplish the evolution of intelligence (to the achievement C+IQ / collective intelligence with ability the speak ), but I have found only "the evolution of emotions". These three processes intersect at one point - baby / human infant that is incapable for independent survival for many years. That is not an evolutionary mistake, on the contrary, that is the key element of my research. By observing it’s mother’s behavior, a process called MSP /multi self-projection passively occurs in baby’s brain when child perceives guardians body as his own. MSP may be the most easily understood as a feeling similar to that of the apparent movement which we have when we are in a train that stands while we are looking through the window at another train that is moving. That way infant’s CNS immediately learns the shortest way to get something done, which enables the creation of many more similar thinking processes till the moment when a minimal number of thinking processes (Adam’s number) are required in order to effect of self-consciousness arise. To connect all that I have mentioned with a huge number of scientific data (Denisovans, Homo naledi, Scientific Adam, Mitochondrial Eve, autism, speech, pleasure in the presence of fire, dreams...) required membership in the Mensa organization... The biggest picture (the framework) for all scientific data (even A.I. because start, origin of original, in making SAI/AGI/HAL 9000 is crucial / what has been missing) is FEST theory.
flipninja (3 years ago)
i think the real question is: why does brad pitt have a tattoo of otzi??
Karl Rove (6 months ago)
Akaaraq Hansen Are you Greenlandic/Danish?
AH96 (1 year ago)
I is a wolf I couldn't believe it either, so I looked it up and found that it's on his forearm
Indigo Eastman (2 years ago)
WAIT WHAT
XxDABOMBxX 90 (3 years ago)
I read the book about ice mummy
Brian Mino (3 years ago)
Archeosoup I gest of course lol :) . How ever if I am not mistaken the proto-Italians started to immigrate to Italy north and south, central about 1300 BC so that would make otzi  an his tribe the pre-italic people as well as prediluvian. No there certainly were  not  romans or pizza or cappuccino in the end of the 'Neolithic perod'' early chalcolithic/bronze age. Copper was first discovered and mined and now  historians call it the copper age lol. Its the beginning of the bronze age. The question is archeosoup just who n fact were these people? My paternal great grandfather was born in the alps of north Italy and guess what ,my paternal YDNA Haplogroup is G2a2B21a. Otzi is my COUSIN! Or should I say my PRE_PASANO!!! CIAO AMICO!!!
Jason Balram (3 years ago)
there is a book about this
Archaeology Soup (3 years ago)
There are many books - the most famous being 'the man in the ice'.
Brian Mino (3 years ago)
He was killed by Roman soldiers.
Claude Röist (8 months ago)
Brian Mino Wtf?
Cuck Hunt1488 (1 year ago)
He died over a thousand years before Rome was even founded!
Archaeology Soup (3 years ago)
Romans weren't around in the Bronze Age.
skamsoff (3 years ago)
it is good to have a tatoo/ tattoo with the name and adress/ pir/
Marky Hulleza (3 years ago)
nepal ancestror is white. . haha
Ryan lex (3 years ago)
Well ancient India are white and indo-European due to the mixing with East Asian Indian skin turn brown.
Didn't musical youth sing about this guy. "Pass the Otzi on the left-hand side."
Traveling man (3 years ago)
looks African to me!
sclock2 (6 months ago)
Oh oh the Kangs have infiltrated the comments
Cuck Hunt1488 (1 year ago)
"Long limbs are very African characteristics" Due you have any actual measurements to prove this assessment? "markings/tattoos similar to many African so called tribes." Tattooing is something White Europeans where known to do since ancient times and it only disapeared with the spread of Christianity. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_tattooing#Europe "Pre-Christian Germanic, Celtic and other central and northern European tribes were often heavily tattooed, according to surviving accounts, but it may also have been normal paint. The Picts may have been tattooed (or scarified) with elaborate, war-inspired black or dark blue woad (or possibly copper for the blue tone) designs. Julius Caesar described these tattoos in Book V of his Gallic Wars (54 BC). Nevertheless, these may have been painted markings rather than tattoos.[26] Ahmad ibn Fadlan wrote of his encounter with the Scandinavian Rus' tribe in the early 10th century, describing them as tattooed from "fingernails to neck" with dark blue "tree patterns" and other "figures."[27] However, this may also have been paint, since the word used can mean both tattoo and painting. During the gradual process of Christianization in Europe, tattoos were often considered remaining elements of paganism and generally legally prohibited." "Asiatic features similar to the Sans people of South Africa." Yes literally he is an African from the part of Africa the absolute farthest part away from where his body was discovered that sounds very likely. Lets ignore this possibility; the current facial shape is due to the effects of mummification. And also lets ignore this fact; there are Whites with no traceable immediate Asian ancestry who have those kinds of features. http://www.nytimes.com/1985/10/08/science/q-a-061233.html https://www.britannica.com/science/epicanthic-fold https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steve_Wozniak "Again another coverup!" In your delusional Kangzy mind. "Also see the Black Madonnas all over europe and ask why they were changed to white." SHIET THE PORTRAITS JUST BE PAINTED OVER AND SHIEEETTT!!! Ignoring the fact there is no evidence for that assertion, I do have to lament over this great irony; whenever Europeans depict figures from the bible as White that is decried as racist conspiratorial whitewashing. But when they depict the figures accurately as middle easterners Kangz use this to Kang about and proclaim that the figures of the bible or Europeans where black and shiiieettt. " I showed this to whites and Asians and they all said it's an African. " Yea, your totally not just talking out of your ass. "Intellectual sciientific dishonesty is nothing new!" Yea, I'm dealing with it right now! "Do you really think lies will be allowed to exist forever?" No, I am destroying lies right now!
Greeny202a (2 years ago)
+Joshua Nguyen Oh it is perhaps better not to ask my friend. There is a strange Afrocentric cult emerged in the US amongst black Americans who are claiming it was actually black Africans who were the first humans in every part of the globe and therefore they suggest old Otzi here was an African. Better to just ignore their lunacy.
Joshua Nguyen (2 years ago)
He was in the Italian alps...how was he African
Greeny202a (3 years ago)
+Traveling man oh i see, you are black American are you. Yes its all a big cover up to prevent the west Africans from discovering their true global history lol.
Thomas (3 years ago)
A 40 -something year old man would have a lot more hair on his chest.
Thomas (3 years ago)
A 40 -something year old man would have a lot more hair on his chest.
shane kaylor (3 years ago)
+PootisPigeon No, not most. It's pretty much 50/50. I have a full pelt, but my dad and both my brothers are practically hairless. And we have German and Italian ancestry. It's all about which genes you get.
Thomas (3 years ago)
+Bryan Trejo Yes, a most white men have genes that give them hairy chests.
Bryan Trejo (3 years ago)
+PootisPigeon hey buddy, ever heard of something miraculous called... genes?
Thomas (3 years ago)
+shane kaylor My father is 54, and he's had the chest of a gorilla for ever, and so has every man I met who isn't a pansy.
shane kaylor (3 years ago)
+PootisPigeon what makes you think that?
The_Disabled_Gamer#2 (3 years ago)
Fascinating how we can find out so much about people of the past cause the ice preserves them and i am sure they have his DNA as well. pretty impressive stuff. RIP my friend, your story has been told and you may now rest in the peace you deserve.
sıdıka mutlubaş (3 years ago)
inanılır gibi değil ...
Emily Castillo (3 years ago)
He was killed because he had an arrow in he right arm
charlix g (3 years ago)
Its most true and amazing discoveries so far!
Emily Castillo (3 years ago)
its real I had studid this in school I learn alot
Emylee Miller (1 year ago)
Same i learned it in school to
Micael G (2 years ago)
+Phyllis Baylock they found blood remains on him and what was left of his clothes and the arrow next to him, they came from 3 random people, not just him guess they still managed to do a blood test. They know how he died because of a big wound that would have killed him for sure, and now he is dead so, it took them decades to figure it out though
About Life (2 years ago)
+Micael G Who made up that story? Was the book of his life found in the ice with his body? Or maybe his killers are still around to tell the real story.
Adoring Fan (3 years ago)
+Micael G well we final have the answer and in that time they had damn tattos?
Micael G (3 years ago)
+Adog 23 I saw more information about him, he was fighting other men, and shot two of them with his bow and only one arrow, also fought and wounded at least one more, later was shot in the back and killed. He also has a lot of tattoos witch I don´t know how they made back then
Madison Brock (3 years ago)
im now learning about otzi
Luchie Pardillo (3 years ago)
my child is 6th grade she even learn ötzi
Linus Magnus (2 years ago)
+Dark Playz I am glad you are aware. If you are an idiot that does not mean I am too.
Trixient (2 years ago)
Linus Magnus YOU WOULD BE DEAD IDIOT!! (I'm aware this comment is a year old)
Asian Vibes (2 years ago)
I'm in 6th grade too
Linus Magnus (3 years ago)
+Luchie Pardillo Thats nothing, I am Otzis brother!
Eagle Boi (3 years ago)
+Schleich Movie I am in 6 grade too
Melanie Dion (3 years ago)
ascinating, we've been learning about this in depth in 6th grade
That0neRob (3 years ago)
I'm also learning about this in social studies and I'm in 6th grade!!!!!!
Nicole Muñoz (3 years ago)
Oh my gosh that's why I watched this video! I'm in sixth grade too and my social studies teacher assigned us homework to gather some facts over the weekend!😀😃😊👚👘
Valentina Iurato (4 years ago)
I first heard about this in 4th grade.
Wendy Churchill (4 years ago)
What's the guy in the bath tub suposet to do with otzi the ice man
+Rayan ALQurashi It's a representation of Eureka, since Archimedes exclaimed it when he was in the tub.
Nogag Atall (4 years ago)
Ötzi was in fact a danish man on a masquerade party in the 80's. He was dressed as a cave-man, got to drunk and fell. He twisted his ankle and fell asleep. He eventually died from starvation, sleeping.
Chrixangez Zq (3 years ago)
+Nogag Atall what?its the truth
Nogag Atall (3 years ago)
+Zhi Qin Stop, you conspirators!
Chrixangez Zq (3 years ago)
+Painted Peppermint I agree with you.That is the real reason after all
Mochirella (3 years ago)
+Nogag Atall NO o-o 
Nogag Atall (3 years ago)
+Painted Peppermint Dane, masquerade, drunk, fell aslepp, died of starvation shortly after.... A very sad story indeed, right?
алекс фан (4 years ago)
А глааное это наколка креста на теле,что обосновывает о глубочайшей вере в бога старых людей!))))) Ловко!))
Stingernukegod (4 years ago)
Just found out that im related to this guy.
Mental Doc (4 months ago)
sclock2 I thought This guy got his dick chopped off
Tom Riddle (1 year ago)
No
Katlyn Baker (1 year ago)
Me too. Hi relative!
Tiffany Baril (1 year ago)
He is right, everyone is related in some kind of way and you don't even know it
Emylee Miller (1 year ago)
Yeah you wish
Moniruzzaman Khan (4 years ago)
Geburtsort R einhold Messners
Vanessa Jiao (4 years ago)
fascinating, we've been learning about this in depth in 6th grade
Katherine Scanlon (3 months ago)
Me too
Kristina Doll (4 months ago)
I learned about him in 7th ! So crazy !
dalton blaser (4 months ago)
Same
don quixote doflamingo (6 months ago)
same
MoonlightPotato (6 months ago)
Us in 8th grade
RTreacts (4 years ago)
cool
yuliana arreguin (4 years ago)
I read about this in sixt grade
MegaFloyd100 (4 years ago)
Why do they even bother carbon dating when they know the results are basically guesswork?
Robot killer (6 months ago)
MegaFloyd100  >the carbons rate of decay carbon's rate of decay is constant, literally because of predictable consequences of physical laws. >without a time machine nobody can know for sure. dumbass argument. by that logic, you can't hold criminal trials because you can't know for sure if someone is guilty of murder despite clear evidence proving it, because you didn't see it happen. science is all about gathering evidence and building up a picture of what happened, not "eureka moments" of 100% proving something true. >They make these assumptions based on the assumed dates of rock strata in which the animal is found.The dates of the rock strata are decided based on their carbon dates.So it is circular logic & totally subjective a blatant lie and a strawman. scientists do not only use 2 dating methods which depend on each other to function, second, CARBON DATING CANNOT BE USED TO DATE FOSSILS YOU RETARD. Carbon dating only works on animals less than 10,000 years old. they have to use other methods to date fossils. Again, proving you don't have any clue what you're talking about. they use other methods to date older fossils. Finally, what about how radiometric dating dates not only *match up with tree rings perfectly*, there's also the fact that DNA dating methods based on average mutation rates also *match up perfectly*? not only that, but the magnetic field changes on the earth effect forming iron-rich rocks in such a way that you can date them, and, guess what, *THEY MATCH UP PERFECTLY*. Getting pretty damned coincidental there, and I didn't even mention all of them, which all match, by the way.
Robot killer (6 months ago)
MegaFloyd100  >evolutionists way to expose yourself, creatard. nobody calls people who believe in real science "evolutionists£ except creationists. yeah, carbon dating has flaws, but what your creatard websites leave out is that scientists discovered those flaws, and take them into account when dating.
joeschultz2 (4 years ago)
+MegaFloyd100  You complained that I gave a "kneejerk" answer to your criticism of the dating of Ötzi.  Then you gave the stock, off-the-shelf argument against the use of carbon 14 dating, along with the now standard reply that a time machine is necessary to measure the age of something in the past.  Of course, the age of something from long ago is measured by a variety of methods, all of them using well established scientific principles, not guesswork.  Carbon 14 dating has its limitations, and these limitations, such as animals from Antarctic sea water cannot be reliably dated, are being laboriously catalogued and calibrated in the science of dating.  Every process has limitations, that does not mean it is useless, as creationists would love to pretend.
MegaFloyd100 (4 years ago)
+joeschultz2 I examined their dating methods for Otzi,& they have vastly improved,& no guesswork is involved at all.Now a time machine is used to go back in time & measure dead organisms for carbon levels immediately after it dies,& then to return at 10,000 year intervals to measure the actual rate of carbon loss & the carbon molecules half-life.Dating methods are perfect.I was a fool.
joeschultz2 (4 years ago)
+MegaFloyd100 You criticized me for a "kneejerk" reaction to your post about the dating "guesswork".  I asked if you had actually examined the  dating of Ötzi specifically.  It appears the short answer to that question is no.
Sheldon David (4 years ago)
who cares
Mochirella (3 years ago)
+Sheldon David I do and other people do, if u don't care then leave x.x
Aaron Trujillo (4 years ago)
I learned about this

Would you like to comment?

Join YouTube for a free account, or sign in if you are already a member.